More Monsignori

This notice from the Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham:

Thursday 21st June 2012

Pope Benedict XVI has elevated three priests of the Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham to the rank of Chaplain of His Holiness (Monsignor). Monsignor Edwin Barnes, Monsignor Robert Mercer, and Monsignor David Silk, have all received the honour from the Holy Father, recognising their former ministry as Anglican bishops. Mgr Barnes and Mgr Silk were received and ordained via the Personal Ordinariate in 2011, whilst Mgr Mercer was received and ordained in 2012.

The Ordinary, Mgr Keith Newton, said “By establishing Personal Ordinariates, Pope Benedict is seeking to be generous in making provision for those Anglicans who wish to come into the full communion of the Catholic Church. In every possible way he has sought to recognise the fruitful Anglican ministry which we undertook before entering the Catholic Church; this honour for these three distinguished men is a further sign of our Holy Father’s love and warmth toward this project”.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Ordination of Edwin Barnes

Edwin Barnes Deacon 180x300 Ordination of Edwin Barnes

The newly-made deacon with his wife, Jane.

From the Ordinariate Portal:

Former Anglican bishop, Edwin Barnes, will be ordained to the sacred order of deacons by the Bishop of Portsmouth, the Rt Revd Crispian Hollis, today. We offer him and his wife, Jane, our prayers and best wishes on this important day for them and for the Personal Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham. May our Lady of Lourdes, whom Jesus can refuse nothing, pray for him.

All of us on The Anglo-Catholic send our best wishes and assurance of prayer!

UPDATE:  There is a first person account of the ordination at Ancient Richborough.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

The Ordinariate Won't Be Quaint or Exotic in the Diocese of Portsmouth

Ordinariate Portal is running this very nice piece on the Ordinariate of Our Lady of Walsingham, which appears in the diocesan magazine, Portsmouth People.

Diocese of Portsmouth: Anglicans’ long journey to Rome nears its end

Portsmouthcatholiccathedral 225x300 The Ordinariate Wont Be Quaint or Exotic in the Diocese of Portsmouth

The Cathedral Church of St John the Evangelist, Portsmouth.

Here in the Diocese of Portsmouth, we are close to having a number of new Catholic neighbours. They are Anglicans in our area hoping to join the Catholic Church under the provisions of the Ordinariate announced more than a year ago by Pope Benedict.

These are exciting but uncertain times for them. Exciting because in Holy Week they should finally be received into full communion with the Church for which they have been yearning for a long time. Uncertain because it’s not yet clear how things will work in practice.

Under the arrangements announced by the Catholic Bishops’ Conference in November there are several stages. Already, by the time you read this edition of Portsmouth People, at least three former Anglican Bishops are likely to have been ordained as Catholic priests to serve in the Ordinariate. In this area, these include the former Bishop of Ebbsfleet, Andrew Burnham, who lives in Abingdon in the north of our diocese. Also Rome will have appointed an ‘Ordinary’ who will be responsible, together with the local Catholic bishop for the ongoing life of the Ordinariate.

Before the beginning of Lent, retired Bishops, including Edwin Barnes the former Bishop of Richborough who lives in Lymington, are also due to be ordained.

Also before the beginning of Lent former Anglican clergymen intending to lead groups of faithful into the Ordinariate will begin ‘a period of intense formation’ for ordination as Catholic priests. In this area, there are expected to be groups from Reading, the Isle of Wight and Christchurch, amounting to a few dozen people in all, though precisely how many is not yet clear.

During Lent, these groups, or candidates as they will be by then, will be prepared for reception into the Church, either on Holy Thursday or during the Easter Vigil. Their pastors, assuming all goes well, will be ordained into the Catholic Priesthood around Pentecost.

Although members of the Ordinariate will not be part of the main structure of our diocese, Bishop Crispian has been involved in making the local arrangements and they will be fellow local Catholics. And we are likely to bump into some of them in our churches. During Lent, before their own pastors are ordained, they may be joining us at Mass. Welcomers take note!

By the summer, the ordinariate groups could have their own Mass times in our churches. And, if they are using our buildings, they make it clear they would help with things like church cleaning and flower arranging. The clergy I have spoken to are all prepared to fill in for our own priests when they are on holiday, and hope that our priests will be able to do the same for them. They are anxious not to be seen, in the words of one, ‘as rather quaint, exotic groups.’

Will the Ordinariate be a temporary or a permanent structure? Former Bishop Andrew is disarmingly honest about this.

‘The first wave will be quite small, but it could be followed by many others, so the Ordinariate would grow.

‘It is also possible that it turns out not to be viable, in which case those in the Ordinariate would fold into the existing Catholic Community. In a way, it doesn’t greatly matter. The important thing is that those called to make the journey have the chance to do so.’

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Our Own Mitred Confirmand

Edwin Barnes 257x300 Our Own Mitred ConfirmandIt is a great pleasure to welcome fellow contributor, Bishop Edwin Barnes into full communion with the Catholic Church.

Bishop Barnes–as I said earlier, I'm not bothering to learn a new name only to learn yet another one in a few weeks–and his wife Jane were received into the Church yesterday.

An account in his own words follows can be found at Ancient Richborough, where he assures us that there was a good bun fight following the service.

The good bishop has been one of the most clear, and enjoyable, voices for the Ordinariate over the last year and his persistence and leadership have been an inspiration to many of us as Anglicanorum coetibus has moved from dream to reality.  His ordination to the priesthood is set for March 5th at Portsmouth Cathedral.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

This One's Close To Home!

This, from the blog of our own dear Bishop Edwin:

Amazing (G)Race
Forgive the punning title, but it does seem to have been a sprint rather than a marathon, heading towards Catholic priesthood. Certainly there has been much grace involved, on the part of the Catholic authorities, from the Holy Father via the Diocesan Bishop and our Parish Priest to the local congregation here. Everyone has done everything possible to smooth our path and make us welcome.

So it is good to be able to announce that the intention is that Jane and I should be received here in Lymington, at the Church of Our Lady and St Joseph, at the 9.30am Mass on January 21st. Bishop Crispian says he will ordain me Deacon in his private chapel on the morning of February 11th, and my ordination to the Priesthood will follow three weeks later at 2.30pm on Saturday March 5th in Portsmouth Catholic Cathedral.

It would be helpful if any Catholic priests who wish to concelebrate in the Cathedral could let me know, so that I can send their names on to the Bishop. But whoever you are reading this blog, please be kind enough to remember Jane and me in your prayers at this exciting and slightly nerve-wracking time.

I guess this means that The Anglo-Catholic will have its very own reporter on the scene! God bless you, Bishop Barnes, and be assured of our prayers as you prepare for these great blessings.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Five Bishops Fly to the Ordinariate for England and Wales

From the excellent Anna Arco at the Catholic Herald:

Five traditionalist Anglican bishops have officially resigned this morning with the intention of taking up an English Ordinariate when it is set up.

This morning, the Rt Rev Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury accepted the resignation of three flying Church of England and two retired assistant bishops in what is a major development in the move towards establishing an Ordinariate in Britain.

The Rt Rev Andrew Burnham, Bishop of Ebbsfleet, the Rt Rev Keith Newton, Bishop of Richborough and Rt Rev John Broadhurst Bishop of Fulham as well as the Rt Rev Edwin Barnes the emeritus Bishop of Richborough and the Rt Rev David Silk, an emeritus assistant bishop of Exeter released a statement announcing their resignations.

They said: “As bishops, we have even-handedly cared for those who have shared our understanding and those who have taken a different view. We have now reached the point, however, where we must formally declare our position and invite others who share it to join us on our journey. We shall be ceasing, therefore, from public episcopal ministry forthwith, resigning from our pastoral responsibilities in the Church of England with effect from 31st December 2010, and seeking to join an Ordinariate once one is created.”

Bishop Newton has been tipped to be the Ordinary of an English Ordinariate when one is established.

The Catholic liason officer for the Ordinariate, Bishop Alan Hopes, an auxiliary of Westminster said: “We welcome the decision of Bishops Andrew Burnham, Keith Newton, John Broadhurst, Edwin Barnes and David Silk to enter into full communion with the Catholic Church through the Ordinariate for England and Wales, which will be established
under the provisions of the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus.”

The bishops are due to discuss the Ordinariate at their plenary meeting next week.

Full statement of the resigning Church of England Bishops:

Like many in the catholic tradition of Anglicanism, we have followed the dialogue between Anglicans and Catholics, the ARCIC process, with prayer and longing. We have been dismayed, over the last thirty years, to see Anglicans and Catholics move further apart on some of the issues of the day, and particularly we have been distressed by developments in Faith and Order in Anglicanism which we believe to be incompatible with the historic vocation of Anglicanism and the tradition of the Church for nearly two thousand years.

The Apostolic Constitution, Anglicanorum cœtibus, given in Rome on 4th November 2009, was a response to Anglicans seeking unity with the Holy See. With the Ordinariates, canonical structures are being established through which we will bring our own experience of Christian discipleship into full communion with the Catholic Church throughout the world and throughout the ages. This is both a generous response to various approaches to the Holy See for help and a bold, new ecumenical instrument in the search for the unity of Christians, the unity for which Christ himself prayed before his Passion and Death. It is a unity, we believe, which is possible only in eucharistic communion with the successor of St Peter.

As bishops, we have even-handedly cared for those who have shared our understanding and those who have taken a different view. We have now reached the point, however, where we must formally declare our position and invite others who share it to join us on our journey. We shall be ceasing, therefore, from public episcopal ministry forthwith, resigning from our pastoral responsibilities in the Church of England with effect from 31st December 2010, and seeking to join an Ordinariate once one is created.

We remain very grateful for all that the Church of England has meant for us and given to us all these years and we hope to maintain close and warm relationships, praying and working together for the coming of God’s Kingdom.

We are deeply appreciative of the support we have received at this difficult time from a whole variety of people: archbishops and bishops, clergy and laity, Anglican and Catholics, those who agree with our views and those who passionately disagree, those who have encouraged us in this step and those who have urged us not to take this step.

The Right Revd Andrew Burnham
The Right Revd Keith Newton
The Right Revd John Broadhurst
The Right Revd Edwin Barnes
The Right Revd David Silk

Bishop Alan Hopes’ full statement:

We welcome the decision of Bishops Andrew Burnham, Keith Newton, John Broadhurst, Edwin Barnes and David Silk to enter into full communion with the Catholic Church through the Ordinariate for England and Wales, which will be established under the provisions of the Apostolic Constitution Anglicanorum Coetibus.

At our plenary meeting next week, the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales will be exploring the establishment of the Ordinariate and the warm welcome we will be extending to those who seek to be part of it. Further information will be made known after the meeting.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Breaking News of a Wonderful Sort…

bpkeith 226x300 Breaking News of a Wonderful Sort... Below is news posted on an  Australian website earlier today. If true, and I strongly suspect it is, then this is thrilling news. Bishop Keith, (who baptised my little girl Jemima Mary), is a very pastoral, wise and wonderful man. Most who meet him speak of his warmth and love and I am personally thrilled that he could be nominated as the Ordinary for England.

BRITAIN'S Archbishop of Canterbury is expected to announce the resignation of two bishops on Monday, in the first of what is feared will be a wave of departures from the Church of England by traditionalists converting to Roman Catholicism.

The Bishop of Richborough, the Right Rev Keith Newton, 58, is expected to become leader of the Anglican Ordinariate, set up to provide Catholic refuge to Anglicans who leave the Church of England over the issue of women bishops.

The Bishop of Ebbsfleet, the Right Rev Andrew Burnham, 63, is also expected to join the Ordinariate, along with the Bishop of Fulham, the Right Rev John Broadhurst, who announced last month that he will be resigning at the end of the year. A fourth retired bishop, Edwin Barnes, is also expected to join the Ordinariate.

Sources said that the Ordinariate is to be launched at Pentecost next year, seven weeks after Easter.

Both Newton and Burnham have been on study leave for the past month while they consider their positions.

The only part of this that I would not take too seriously is the mention of a wave. The first batch of leavers will be small as it needs both a committed priest and ready and willing congregation. It is the second wave that I think will be larger but even then it should not worry the Church of England too much. The Ordinariate offers a sanctuary and mission base for those wanting to worship as traditional Catholics but it also frees the Church of England to proceed with Women Bishops and create a more liberal, congregationalist and protestant shaped Church for the 21st Century.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Two More Posts Concerning the Ordinariates

I've now added a couple more articles to finish the quaternity of my Roman-observed posts concerning the implementation of the Ordinariates in England and Wales.  I hope they may be of interest and help, though I add once more that I offer them diffidently.

The third article, as I suggested in my last post, concerns the financial possibilities for those seeking the Ordinariates; how body and soul are to be kept together.  I've addressed this before (on this site, in fact), but it seems, understandably, to be one of the most pressing worries of prospective Tibernauts.  You can read it here.

The fourth post concerns the practical establishment of the Ordinariate, and a suggestion of how those interested, clergy and laity may become involved in it.  A kind comment made by Bishop Edwin Barnes suggests that I am not entirely off target, and also observes that clergy and laity who have not yet signalled their interest should hurry up and do so  You can read this post here.

My prayers and good wishes continue to be with you all, as well as my congratulations to Christian Campbell for maintaining such a splendid resource at this very exciting time.  I pray that some time soon we may be celebrating the Holy Mass in union, as our Lord intended.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Bishop Edwin's Interview with InfoCatólica

A few days ago, Bruno Moreno of the Spanish-language online newspaper InfoCatólica submitted an interview request in the form of a comment on Bishop Barnes' post First Things First asking for him or another contributor from The Anglo-Catholic to share some insights about Anglo-Catholicism, a movement unfamiliar to his audience.  Bishop Barnes graciously consented to the interview and it has just been published here.  An English translation is provided below.

* * *

How would you define an Anglo-Catholic?

The Church of England contains many varieties of Christians. Those who are nearer to the Catholic understanding of Scripture, Tradition and the Church, and who express this in their language (speaking, for instance, of the Altar, rather than the Holy Table) and their practice (celebrating the Eucharist regularly and frequently, in many churches not simply every week, but every day) would be called ‘Anglo-Catholic’.

You have been an Anglican bishop for the past fifteen years. What has been your role as a ‘flying bishop’?

In 1992 the central Council of our Church, the General Synod, decided that women might be ordained to the priesthood. In doing so it also said that those who did not accept this innovation must have provision made for them to enable them to continue as faithful Anglicans. For this purpose each Archbishop (there are two in England) consecrated one or two bishops, themselves opposed to women’s ordination, to minister to individuals and congregations who voted to ask for such extra provision. They were suffragans of the Archbishops, and so known as Provincial Episcopal Visitors (PEV’s) or, colloquially, ‘flying bishops’. My remit, for six years from 1995-2001, was to travel the length and breadth of the Eastern half of the Canterbury Province. I was consecrated to the See of Richborough – a title taken from the site where St Augustine set foot in England on his mission from Pope Gregory. On my retirement I became simply a super-numerary and honorary bishop in the diocese where I live, Winchester. My successor as Bishop of Richborough is Bishop Keith Newton.

Did the creation by Pope Benedict XVI of new Personal Ordinariates for Anglicans who wish to enter full communion with the Catholic Church come as a surprise for you?

The Holy Father’s initiative, directed at Groups of Anglicans, came as a great and very welcome surprise.

Many people ask “why now?” If Anglo-Catholics wish to seek communion with the See of Rome, why have they waited until now? Is it just a matter of women bishops or something deeper?

Many of us have believed that the Church of England was moving, for the past century at least, in an ever more catholic direction. With the international conversations between the Anglican Communion and Rome (the ARCIC Conversations) we believed and hoped there would be corporate reunion for us in our lifetime. Since the ordination of women to the priesthood, and now the likelihood of their consecration as bishops, that has faded as an impossible dream.

What are the main elements of the Anglican Patrimony you would like the Ordinariates to preserve?

Our fathers in the faith spoke of “reserve” in matters of faith. That is, a sort of quiet and simple spirit in the best of Anglican use. It has seemed to me a religious voice, a tone, in keeping with our national character. The language of our Prayer Book which introduced the vernacular into our worship five centuries ago seems to catch something of this plain, undemonstrative but deeply felt religious sensibility. But in truth, I think we cannot discover our Patrimony until we see it in a completely Catholic context.

Do you expect the Anglican Ordinariates to attract many people in England and Wales? Will whole parishes take the plunge?

It is difficult at present to see how it will be possible for entire parishes to join the Ordinariate, simply because the Church of England is very territorial, and will not readily part with, for instance, its buildings. For all that, there are several priests I know who are preparing their congregations, and who will take the first opportunity of belonging whether they can retain their parish churches or not.

Do you believe some Anglican Bishops will enter the Ordinariates? Are you personally planning to avail yourself of this opportunity?

Certainly I know of several Bishops who are exploring the possibility, as I am myself. I can see no other future for catholics in the Church of England than this.

Would you be willing to seek ordination in the Roman Catholic Church? Would you consider ordination or whatever your role is in the Ordinariate a denial of your pastoral work in the Anglican Communion or rather a culmination of that work?

Because the Holy Father’s appeal is to Groups of Anglicans, I believe my personal future is unimportant compared with what is offered to us all. If it is decided that my ministry can continue, and that I may be ordained a Priest in the Catholic Church, then I should be delighted – but I should join the Ordinariate unconditionally, and let others decide whether there might still be something for me to undertake. I am sure that the simple fact of joining the Ordinariate will be the crown and completion of my ministry up to this point.

What are the main difficulties you envisage in this adventure, both for yourself and for most Anglo-Catholics? Will the need to accept the faith of the Roman Catholic Church as proclaimed by the Catechism be an obstacle for many Anglo-Catholics?

I think for some Anglicans there are stumbling blocks within the Catechism. We have been separated from the Catholic mainstream for five hundred years, and there have been developments in doctrine with which we are unfamiliar. As a frequent visitor to Fatima, I have no difficulty with the Marian dogmas. There was a time when I found it hard to accept the Immaculate Conception (for I did not properly understand it) and Papal Infallibility. Others may still find these to be difficulties for them – I do not. And I hope and believe the Church will be very understanding and patient in explaining these matters. Far more important for me is the readiness of the Holy Father to accept and ordain men who have been married Anglican clergy. My wife has been a great help and adornment to my ministry, and I am glad there is the possibility that, should I be ordained a Catholic priest, this would continue.

Some members of the Ordinariates will come from the Anglican Communion, while others will come from different groups, such as the Traditional Anglican Communion, or even from Anglican Use parishes? Do you think that diversity will be a problem?

I believe that Anglicans in North America and elsewhere have been in such difficult situations that for them actual schism from the Anglican Communion has been necessary. I know several such priests and parishes, and have no doubt that we shall learn from one another and come to value one another. One of my greatest friends is a Priest of the Anglican Use in Texas, and I think he and I have more in common than I do with most of those in England who call themselves members of our church.

Do the Anglican Ordinariates have a future in the Catholic Church? How do you envisage them in, say, one hundred years?

I believe the Catholic Church is very patient; and I am sure she will want to learn from this experiment. I hope, personally, that the experience of a married priesthood might at some future date enable the Church to recognise that it is possible to have a double vocation, to the priesthood and to holy matrimony. I am greatly impressed by the way the Holy Father has introduced Anglicanorum Coetibus, making it clear that this is not a short-term solution to present-day problems, but a generous open offer for many years, perhaps centuries, to come. So who knows, it may be that eventually the Church of England will indeed return to her roots and become part of the One, Holy Catholic and Apostolic Church which she has always claimed to be.

How will the leaving (maybe we might say expelling) of Anglo-Catholics affect the Anglican Communion? Would it mean the end of its claim to be a branch of the Catholic Church? Do you expect the Anglican Communion to change much in the following years or decades?

It seems to me we are witnessing the break-up of the Anglican Communion – which was always a rather anomalous fruit of Empire. Gradually individual national churches will, I think, either join the Catholic Church, or dwindle into some amorphous protestant body, incapable of making any real witness to society.

What will the Roman Catholic Church gain by the ‘coming home’ of the Anglo-Catholics?

I hope we shall all gain enormously from this home-coming; it will be a reunion of friends, to replace the Parting of Friends of which Newman spoke.

How is Card. Newman regarded by Anglo-Catholics? Will you attend his beatification in September? Would you like to see him as one of the patron saints of the Ordinariates?

I believe John Henry Cardinal Newman has had a hand in what is happening in England today. Many of us are very glad to have him as a fellow-countryman. If I were permitted to be at his beatification I can think of no greater honour; and whether or not he is named as a patron of the Ordinariates, I am sure we should all be seeking his prayers at this wonderful time.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Dealing with Change

Fr. Ed Tomlinson, SSC, parish priest of St. Barnabas, Royal Tunbridge Wells, has written to commend the following piece on the necessity of coming to terms with the understandable — but inevitable — anxieties caused by the advent of the anticipated personal ordinariate in England and Wales, and the imperative of placing the demands of Catholic faith above relative (temporal) security and comfort.  A few days ago, our own Bishop Barnes wrote about the cold feet being experienced by some notable Anglo-Catholic clerics (and again today); perhaps Fr. Tomlinson's article will help further the debate between Bishop Edwin and Fr. Jones.

* * *

cardinal newman ouless 202x300 Dealing with ChangeCardinal Newman is a beacon of hope to those, myself included, hoping to avail themselves of the Ordinariate.  I recently returned to his autobiography – 'Apologia pro vita sua' – and found it useful for one contemplating the exciting journey.  Furthermore I feel Newman’s prayers are close to Anglo-Catholics at this historic moment and that he is willing us on from heaven.  May he lead us to safe pasture where Catholic truth is embraced and not treated with contempt and suspicion.

Whilst on holiday my mind kept returning to something bugging me at present — namely the lack of enthusiasm amongst many Anglo-Catholics!  I speak of those who, despite praying for reunion for years, are now acting as if the very possibility of being in communion with Peter is the end to all we hold dear.  How warped but revealing this is!

I do not speak of those asking questions or probing the agenda to advance its cause but of those who know in their hearts that they are going nowhere.  Why do they look for problems with a louder voice than they give public thanks?  Why pour cold water on the Ordinariate despite it being the ONLY show in town?  Why continue to look to an unloving synod when the Holy Father himself is now calling us to safety?  They remind me of the people in Jesus’ parable who had dead to bury and fields to plow — the finding of good excuses to mask a refusal to follow where He calls.

I suspect such people are not scared of an Ordinariate so much as terrified of risk and change.  Fear grips and they want to bury heads in the sand.  Or else they have grown far too content moaning on the fringes of an increasingly liberal establishment to risk or sacrifice comfort in pursuit of God’s truth!  Does the dreadful state of modern Anglicanism not bother them?  Do they not think the rejection of marriage and acceptance of serial monogamy (gay or straight) are serious salvation issues?  Nor think the silence on abortion is an affront to our Lord?  The acceptance of priests who do not believe?  The desire to please the world that trumps an ability to stand up for the Gospel?

Little wonder such people are angry!  The offer of an Ordinariate not only calls their bluff but wrecks the entire party!  Where is the integrity in defending a tiny Catholic tradition once you refuse to be part of the Catholic faith?  Any claim of Catholicity from those opting to stay — that is opting for communion with Schori, Gene Robinson et al instead of the Pope — will sound as funny to many as it sounds disingenous.

Perhaps Newman can help.  For he reminds us that fear is not a motive and nor is refusal to change.  However much we might desire that God suspends time — to keep us comfortable in our cosy ghettos — it ain't gonna happen.  So listen to Newman again: ‘to live is to change and to be perfect is to have changed often.’  Change is at the heart of the Gospel and change is what needs embracing once again.

Life does not stand still.  And however much we yearn to exist in ‘comfort zones’ these are never the places where we grow and develop.  I can not think of a single biblical hero who pleased God by considering salaries, housing or buildings — but I can think of dozens who learnt the meaning of faith through sacrifice, change and obedience.  We go into the Ordinariate not because we know it will work but because it is the only way we can stand up for our understanding of the faith with integrity.  If we really DO uphold Catholic doctrine then how can we possibly opt for Canterbury over Rome given the current state of both churches?

The call to join the Ordinariate is challenging then but cannot — and must not — be avoided.  We must embrace uncomfortable/risky change to stand up for our Catholic convictions.  Only this will demonstrate to others that we are Gospel people, a people desiring of truth.  To remain where we are will now smack of compromise given the statements we have made.

That is to say we can no longer pretend that the Anglican church offers a genuine ‘Catholic’ home, is part of the Church Universal, after the numerous heretical decisions of recent years.  To do that would be deeply dishonest and I think every Anglo-Catholic knows this in their heart.  Nor can we imagine that we have the ability to return it to a place of true orthodoxy when almost ALL theological colleges, Cathedrals and seats of power are now in the grip of liberal theologians.  To believe this is bordering on being delusional and the report of the Revision Committee reveals as much.  The very most we can hope for is to be left alone to slowly die out languishing in the margins whilst preaching a faith that does not resonate in any other part of the Church we belong to.  What a dreary prospect that is!

This is why logic dictates that the Anglo-Catholic Movement can only be leading to a place of upheaval and change.  The experiment born in the 19th Century is now over and this reality HAS to be faced.  I think that any impartial person with half a brain could tell us that much!  So we can either remain where we are and sink into history without trace within one generation or rejoice in the truly wonderful fact that the experiment ended in glory — the glory of communion with Rome.

Thus we have no option at present but to be brave and accept thing.  What is the Ordinariate if not the solution from God?  What is the point of being Anglo-Catholic if we opt to remain within a Church that stands for everything BUT the Catholic faith?!  Especially when we have the invitation to stand with true Catholics!

Again Newman can inspire us.  He too battled internally as he made momentous decisions.  He too embraced change in order to enter communion with Peter and live out the faith with integrity.  And having done so he found peace: “From the day I became a Catholic to this day, now close upon thirty years, I have never had a moment’s misgiving that the communion of Rome is that Church which the Apostles set up at Pentecost.”

The time for bravery is here and it is now.  Let us get our people ready.  Let us pray with joy in our hearts.  Let us stand up for what we truly believe!  And let us stamp out the negativity at this most vital and thrilling moment of our lifetime.

The Catholic Movement was always meant to be that — a MOVEMENT.  Why did we join it if we only wanted to stand still?  Why do we still pray for the Pope at Mass if we have no intention of joining him?  And why teach the Catholic faith at all if our real desire is to serve a protestant body that is so clearly now leading to a liberal conclusion?  Those seeking integrity in debate must answer these questions if they wish to make a case for remaining.  I cannot for the life of me see how they will do it.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!