Anglican Use Conference: Final Report

The second and final day of the annual Anglican Use Conference began as the first day did, with Morning Prayer according to the Book of Divine Worship in the crypt chapel of the Cathedral in Newark. On this Memorial of the Immaculate Heart of Mary, Father Davis delivered a moving and powerful sermon lamenting the absence of Our Lady from the devotions of Anglo-Catholic churches.

The final session of the conference on Saturday morning began as Dr. Anne Barbeau Gardiner, Professor Emerita of English at John Jay College of the City University of New York, presented a fascinating history of great literary beauty on the English convert kings of the 17th century.

In response to a question about publication of the papers delivered at the conference, Steve Cavanaugh again confirmed that they would be published in Anglican Embers, the quarterly journal of the Anglican Use Society, and that in addition some of the material would be provided on the Society website.

The conference continued with a question-and-answer session with Bishop Juan Ignacio Arrieta, introduced by Msgr. Sheehan. This was a follow-up to the Bishop’s canonical discussion of the personal ordinariates as presented to the conference the previous evening. Among the questions presented were two from Fr. Bergman, one relating to the status of individuals originally baptized outside of the Anglican tradition, but fully initiated through Confirmation within the Pastoral Provision. The second question concerned the manner in which Church real property might be held under the ordinariates, specifically, would church property be held in the name of the ordinariate, or in the name of the local diocese, or in some other form? Bishop Arrieta was thoughtful and gracious in his answers, and took the occasion to underscore the importance of cooperation between the personal ordinaries and the diocesan ordinaries, but it was clear that these and other details have yet to be worked out.

Bishop Arrieta was warm, friendly, and sincerely interested in the concerns of both the Pastoral Provision community and the Anglicans who are discerning reconciliation. As a curial official in the Holy See, Bishop Arrieta may be in a position to make the pastoral concerns of both groups better understood in Rome. Mr. Blake, Archbishop Myers and Monsignor Sheehan were farsighted and prudent in inviting the Bishop to participate in the conference. And in his partcipation, Bishop Arrieta demonstrated that he is more than a scholar and canonist, but is also, as befits the grace of his orders, a kind and thoughtful pastor of souls. I pray that the Bishop will be consulted by the Holy Father and the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.

Before the conference adjourned, the final appearance was by the Traditional Anglican Communion Bishops. Archbishop John Hepworth, Bishop Carl Reid and Bishop David Moyer, who had been present throughout the conference, stood before the assembly while Archbishop Hepworth spoke with feeling, describing the way in which the churches of the TAC (ACA in the United States of America) will proceed as the ordinariates are established. (Archbishop Louis Falk had been present throughout the first day of the conference but was unavailable during this session.)

This is not the proper forum, and I am not the proper reporter, to interpret the Bishops' intent. There are important pastoral issues to be considered as these Bishops work with their people, and it is clear that the Bishops will do this work with great love and great sensitivity. I hope it will be sufficient in this forum to say that the conference was most favorably impressed with the remarks of Archbishop Hepworth, and that the conference expressed a clear message of approbation and welcome with an enthusiastic standing ovation for these Bishops that was the concluding event of the conference. Clearly this is a time of great hope and great promise for the people of the Traditional Anglican Communion and for the cause of Christian unity.

Following the adjournment of the conference, the Anglican Use Society conducted its annual meeting, which was open to all present. Then, at noon, the concluding Mass of the conference was offered in the crypt chapel of the Cathedral Basilica.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Anglican Use Conference: End of Day One Report

Following the Anglican Use Pastors Panel, the conference went into recess to prepare for Mass.

In the annual tradition of the Anglican Use Conference, all present were invited to join in the pickup choir for the Mass. At least two dozen conference attendees availed themselves of the opportunity, and off they went to a 3:30 pm rehearsal, while others went to confession at 4:00 pm or retired to one of the many informal discussion groups.

Solemn High Mass was offered at 5:00 pm at the high altar of the Cathedral. Our group did not quite fill the pews of the massive basilica, but mindful of Anglican tradition we did our best to fill the space with our hymns and chants. Mass was according to the Book of Divine Worship, with traditional Anglican plainsong. Most present either knew the chants or ably sight read them. Archbishop Myers pontificated, and the principal celebrant was Retired Bishop Jeffrey Steenson. The choir performed admirably, and, yes, we did have an opportunity to hear the cathedral’s extraordinary pipe organ. What an inspiring sight it was to see members of our two groups worshiping together according to our common liturgy, exchanging warm greetings at the sign of peace, separated from full communion by the width of the Tiber, but praying together for unity.

After Mass the group returned to the chancery office building where Archbishop Myers was our host for dinner. Archbishop Myers praised the work over the decades of Monsignor William Stetson, a priest of Opus Dei and the long-time secretary to the Ecclesiastical Delegate for the Pastoral Provision. Monsignor Stetson received a standing ovation. His successor as secretary, Monsignor James Sheehan, served as master of ceremonies at the dinner.

After dinner, Monsignor Sheehan introduced the keynote speaker, his former canon law professor Bishop Juan Ignacio Arrieta, the Secretary of the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts, who had traveled from Rome for the occasion. Bishop Arrieta presented his paper entitled Personal Ordinariates. This detailed presentation of nine single-spaced pages was both canonical and pastoral in its approach and sensitivities, and reflected Bishop Arrieta’s professional interest in ecclesiology. The canonist’s presentation confirmed much of the analysis that was evident from the plain language of the Apostolic Constitution and was presented at the Anglicanorum Coetibus Information Day at Our Lady of the Atonement parish last December. Additionally, Bishop Arrieta presented for the first time new insights on the dual membership of personal ordinariate members in both the ordinariate and the territorial diocese. The Bishop explained that, while this is not explicit in Anglicanorum Coetibus or the Complementary Norms, membership in a particular church must be inferred from the ecclesiological principles set out in Communionis Notio (1992). Bishop Arrieta also gave great emphasis to two points that are known but that the canonist felt were essential to a complete understanding, first, that it is canonically significant that those joining a personal ordinariate must voluntarily and affirmatively express their intent to do so (and may voluntarily withdraw at any time), and second, that the cooperation between the personal ordinary and diocesan bishops as called for in the Apostolic Constitution will be very important.

The Bishop also noted that, while exceptions are provided for, clerical celibacy as called for by Canon Law in the Latin Rite will be the rule in the ordinariates, and that this will be important for the future formation side-by-side of seminarians from the ordinariate and from the local diocese.

Bishop Arrieta’s paper, and the others given at the conference, will be published in Anglican Embers, the quarterly journal of the Anglican Use Society.

The final day of the conference will be tomorrow, Saturday June 12.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Anglican Use Conference: Day One Afternoon Report

Following Morning Prayer and the greeting from Archbishop Myers, the conference reconvened in morning session in the auditorium of the Archdiocesan chancery office.

The first speaker, Sister Elaine, ASSP, reflected on the experience of her religious community, All Saints Sisters of the Poor. A long-established order in the Church of England, the sisters first came to Baltimore in 1872, have been in Baltimore continuously ever since, and were received into full communion last September by Archbishop O’Brien of Baltimore.

As Sister Elaine explained, much of the sisters’ daily life remains unchanged, as Archbishop O’Brien had instructed them “keep doing what you’re doing.” For example, the form of their daily office remains unchanged, with the Sisters offering the liturgy of the hours six times daily as a community. Sister Elaine’s presentation was filled with joy, and was frequently punctuated with laughter, as when she explained that not every one understands the monastic life, as demonstrated by the advice she received to “get a job,” perhaps teaching in a Catholic school.

Sister Elaine describes her community’s journey into full communion matter-of-factly as “becoming Roman Catholic.” Sister emphasized the importance of promoting vocations to the religious life and said that she was counting on the parishes represented in the room to send her at least one postulant.

Next up on the program was Dr. William Oddie’s presentation on the important role of influential and literarily sophisticated Anglican converts in Catholic apologetics. Dr. Oddie is a well respected and widely published Church of England clergyman who was received into full communion in 1991.

What could have been a disappointing experience was transformed into a particularly edifying and entertaining experience when, on learning that for health reasons he would be unable to travel to Newark, Dr. Oddie asked Father Allan Hawkins to deliver the paper for him. Today, Fr. Hawkins is best known to us as the pastor of St. Mary the Virgin, the Pastoral Provision parish in Arlington, Texas. Earlier, Fathers Oddie and Hawkins had served together in England, and clearly know each other well. Fr. Hawkins’ annotated reading of the paper brought to life Dr. Oddie’s animated reflections on Chesterton, and the synergy of Chesterton, Oddie and Hawkins greatly exceeded the sum of the parts.

Following a thorough and thoroughly entertaining discussion of Newman and Chesterton, Oddie’s paper went to on to discuss more recent developments. Dr. Oddie made clear his view that last fall, Pope Benedict suddenly accelerated the timetable for the publication of Anglicanorum Coetibus, before its intent could be frustrated by those who oppose the new Apostolic Constitution.

Lunch was an occasion for informal discussions, with clergy and lay people from ACA, other Continuing and Episcopalian parishes dining in small groups with Pastoral Provision folks.

The afternoon conference session was the annual tradition of the Anglican Use Pastors Panel. This is always a crowd favorite, as the audience has the opportunity to define the agenda. This year’s panelists were Fr. James Ramsey of Our Lady of Walsingham in Houston, Fr. Richard Bradford of St. Athanasius in Boston, Fr. Allan Hawkins of St. Mary the Virgin in Arlington, Fr. Jean Hart, SOLT, of St Anselm of Canterbury in Corpus Christi, Fr. Eric Bergman of St. Thomas More in Scranton, Fr. Ernest Davis of St. Therese Little Flower in Kansas City, and Deacon Oliver Vietor of St. Paul’s in Phoenix. In keeping with the issues of the day, questions and comments from the audience leaned heavily toward issues of priestly ordination and the future of the ordinariates.

Going into the pastors’ panel, most conference attendees probably had the sense that the mood of the room was a watchful and somewhat impatient eagerness for the Church “to get on with” the ordinariates. After hearing the tone and content of the questions, this mood was unmistakable.

Bishop Juan Ignacio Arrieta, a distinguished canon lawyer who serves as Secretary of the Pontifical Council for Legislative Texts, and who is the keynote speaker for the conference, was present for the Pastors' Panel and followed the discussion with animated interest.

Your humble scribe is a cradle Catholic who has worshiped in a Pastoral Provision parish for six years, and, like most Anglican Use parishioners, is eager for the U.S. ordinariate to be established. After talking with these conference attendees, I can see that the need is even greater among our Anglican brethren who are waiting. In a particularly challenging situation are the clergy of the ACA, other Continuing groups, and Episcopal Church groups who are working hard to serve the pastoral needs of the people, while at the same time holding their flocks together under extreme uncertainty about the timing. Let us hope that Rome is reading the blogs.

Further reports will be posted as time allows.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!

Anglican Use Conference: Day One Mid-day Report

This morning, in the reverberant crypt chapel beneath the Cathedral Basilica of the Sacred Heart in Newark, more than a hundred Catholic and Anglican voices rang out in the words of the General Thanksgiving as the annual Anglican Use Conference began with Morning Prayer according to the Book of Divine Worship.

Following Morning Prayer, and before leaving the crypt chapel, the conferees were greeted by our host, the Most Reverend John Myers, Archbishop of Newark and Ecclesiastical Delegate for the Pastoral Provision. Invoking the words of our Lord Jesus in John 17 “that they all may be one,” the Archbishop wished us well in our work. We will see our host again at 5:00 pm for the Solemn High Mass at the high altar of the magnificent basilica which the Archbishop quite rightly called a “great work of art.”

Morning sessions were held in the auditorium of the Archdiocesan offices across the street from the Cathedral, and conferees will shortly reconvene for a lunch program. A more detailed report will be posted as time permits, but so far the meeting is characterized by great good will and cheerful collaboration.

* * *

Be sure to follow our Moderator at Eccentric Bliss, his personal blog!